Not all whys are answered!
When my daughter asks me Why?? for a lot of things I don't have answers immediately. Sometimes I can answer her queries but for a lot of them I beg for time. For the factual stuff I look up the internet and remember to tell her over the coming days. Sometimes, though, she has forgotten her own question and is not very interested:) Seeing her elder sis at it, another little voice often puts up her set of questions beginning with 'Wallom' (actually should be Waarom: Why, can't pronounce the r :-).
Yesterday, Big G narrated something disturbing to me. She was talking to a friend's son, S, who is a year senior to her in school, (1st std and 2nd std) when a group of boy's from S's class started teasing them, saying , allee (come on) kiss him. She was very upset and angry when she got home, asking me why they said something like that. I asked her what she had done - she said nothing, she just stopped talking to S, and felt uncomfortable. Did she go to the teacher, she shook her head.
I did not know what to tell her, rather how nuanced it ought to be. I told her that she can choose whom she talks to in school and there is nothing wrong in talking to boys/girls she is friendly with. Other people have no right to interfere or comment when you are talking to somebody and if they do so, you must ignore them. If they persist in pestering you, inform the teacher on the play area.
Then, more importantly kissing is a show of affection which we do to our family mostly and to our special friends - example greeting them with a kiss (kiss on the cheeks only) or on their birthdays. We do not go around kissing people in schools or randomly, it's just not done. We go to school to learn new things, be part of a large group of people and play and interact together. If at any part of the process you are not comfortable with anything, you must talk to your Mama and Daddy at home and your teacher in school. We have a responsibility to resolve it for you.
I am not sure if all this has sunk in, I will of course have to repeat it over and over again. Today, she told me she did not encounter those boys again. I spoke to S's mother and she said that her own son had not said anything to her. Bullying is a part of school dynamics, like it or not. She even hinted that possibly we are targeted because of our skin colour. Another friend said that kids here at this young age are conscious about boy-girl interaction and maybe even about sex. I did not want to make a big deal about this incident with Big G because after all she is all of 6 years old.
I did not want to tell her that this is the first instance in the process of growing up as a girl, never mind which corner of the world. I don't want to be the cynic who says watch out, for every step she takes. She is still a baby and so innocent.
One thing I have realized in staying here is integration is not easy. Because of the language it's even more difficult and a lot of people just give up and live in little islands of nationalities and communities. Perhaps it is a bit easier for people who work but for the rest no idea. The cultural differences are too many and on many levels. I don't understand why parents just give up on their kids when they become 18 years of age? No interference, no guidance, most of the times. When I see teens who are smoking casually, hanging out as couples flaunting PDA, the show of skin which does not raise any eyebrows, and wonder which of these will end up in the next episode of 'Tiener Moeders' (Teenage Mothers). Or am I getting more regressive as I age? One of my friends told me that DPS school sells condoms or some such but surely that is not representative of the whole of India.
My daughter's friends are children from other nationalities. Well, she does have one Belgian friend who stays closeby. When I asked if she could go and play with her classmate on an afternoon for an hour, the grandmother told me she will consult her agenda and let me know. That was a year ago!!! Well, I certainly have apprehensions about a lot of things here. Would love to hear from people who have stayed here for a longer time and how they've resolved these issues. Till then it continues to remain #immigrant'sproblems #expatissues #Belgiumblues.
Yesterday, Big G narrated something disturbing to me. She was talking to a friend's son, S, who is a year senior to her in school, (1st std and 2nd std) when a group of boy's from S's class started teasing them, saying , allee (come on) kiss him. She was very upset and angry when she got home, asking me why they said something like that. I asked her what she had done - she said nothing, she just stopped talking to S, and felt uncomfortable. Did she go to the teacher, she shook her head.
I did not know what to tell her, rather how nuanced it ought to be. I told her that she can choose whom she talks to in school and there is nothing wrong in talking to boys/girls she is friendly with. Other people have no right to interfere or comment when you are talking to somebody and if they do so, you must ignore them. If they persist in pestering you, inform the teacher on the play area.
Then, more importantly kissing is a show of affection which we do to our family mostly and to our special friends - example greeting them with a kiss (kiss on the cheeks only) or on their birthdays. We do not go around kissing people in schools or randomly, it's just not done. We go to school to learn new things, be part of a large group of people and play and interact together. If at any part of the process you are not comfortable with anything, you must talk to your Mama and Daddy at home and your teacher in school. We have a responsibility to resolve it for you.
I am not sure if all this has sunk in, I will of course have to repeat it over and over again. Today, she told me she did not encounter those boys again. I spoke to S's mother and she said that her own son had not said anything to her. Bullying is a part of school dynamics, like it or not. She even hinted that possibly we are targeted because of our skin colour. Another friend said that kids here at this young age are conscious about boy-girl interaction and maybe even about sex. I did not want to make a big deal about this incident with Big G because after all she is all of 6 years old.
I did not want to tell her that this is the first instance in the process of growing up as a girl, never mind which corner of the world. I don't want to be the cynic who says watch out, for every step she takes. She is still a baby and so innocent.
One thing I have realized in staying here is integration is not easy. Because of the language it's even more difficult and a lot of people just give up and live in little islands of nationalities and communities. Perhaps it is a bit easier for people who work but for the rest no idea. The cultural differences are too many and on many levels. I don't understand why parents just give up on their kids when they become 18 years of age? No interference, no guidance, most of the times. When I see teens who are smoking casually, hanging out as couples flaunting PDA, the show of skin which does not raise any eyebrows, and wonder which of these will end up in the next episode of 'Tiener Moeders' (Teenage Mothers). Or am I getting more regressive as I age? One of my friends told me that DPS school sells condoms or some such but surely that is not representative of the whole of India.
My daughter's friends are children from other nationalities. Well, she does have one Belgian friend who stays closeby. When I asked if she could go and play with her classmate on an afternoon for an hour, the grandmother told me she will consult her agenda and let me know. That was a year ago!!! Well, I certainly have apprehensions about a lot of things here. Would love to hear from people who have stayed here for a longer time and how they've resolved these issues. Till then it continues to remain #immigrant'sproblems #expatissues #Belgiumblues.
I like the way u explained things to Big G. AS you said, the message would have to be drilled in unonstrusively, many times.
ReplyDeleteCan't really comment (though can empathise) with the cultural differences/issues since I've never lived in such an environment. My only experience has been in a very cosmpolitan English-speaking part of the world with a large desi network to boot. So what I learnt is not that relevant.
Would be interested in seeing what others have to say. S and I do want to stay somewhere in europe for a few years but are aware that it comes with its own set of challenges.
Thank's Aparna! I think we have to keep talking to our children. Yes it is tough, especially for women who stay at home and some of them even have admitted to feelings of depression, isolation, which is sad. I'm one of them:) We don't have a big network here because we are not v. social people, which I sometimes see as a drawback. All the best for your dream, and hope it goes well for you.
ReplyDeleteIndia is also changing, though not everything to better, we going the west way...and i am sure that in next 20 years we shall also see the same problems in drugs, teenage mothers, children being adopted and all that..
ReplyDeleteI think that if one keeps talking to children and live themselves with certain values, they will automatically get passed to them and ingrained in them.
Yes Renuji, India is changing, for for better or worse is highly debatable. Also, what we see and hear is only about town and cities, in the villages I wonder how much change has seeped in. Change and progress is good, but should it affect our basic values and sense of right and wrong? Totally agree with what you say about talking to children and instilling values.
DeleteI'm not sure if the issue is a cultural one or a generational one. I believe youngsters today have a different set of morals than what we had and we had a different set compared to our parents. I understand the other incidents that occurred to you may have you thinking that this may be because you all are expats.
ReplyDeleteI think you handled Big G's dilemma really well! I'm sure she will continue to come to you if and when she has such issues in the future!
Possibly Roshni, I understand where you are coming from, but at this young age I would want her to know what is acceptable or totally wrong. As she grows up she will work it out for herself. Thanks, I only hope she let's me know what happens at school, and more importantly about stuff that is bothering her.
DeleteBy the way, in appreciation of my readers and commentors, I posted this today: http://www.bigaandlittlea.com/2012/12/top-commentors.html. Do come over and check it out!
DeleteI feel that you are doing fine as a mother. It is good that you have got such a beautiful blogger platform to share your thoughts. Have a lovely weekend CW.
ReplyDeleteThanks Kavita, nice to see you here. Hope you are doing well now! Agree about the blogger platform, helps to share thoughts and get feedback and different points of view.
DeleteChattywren, I really liked the way you handled the situation with your daughter and explained it so well to her. I'm sure she must be secure and reassured now. And I think that is very imperative when raising your child. At the end of the day, if our children feel reassured that they can come to us anytime for support and if we as parents have ensured to make them feel secure then I think there isnt much to worry.
ReplyDeleteSo dont worry!
Thanks Deeps, I really hope so. We can't protect our kids from all kinds of situations so the best we can do is to know what's right or wrong, and be resourceful to resolve it for themselves.
ReplyDeleteThat was very beautifully explained to big G, Vibha! I am sure Big G will feel reassured and will come back to you if and when she is bothered by something..
ReplyDeleteI will look out comments on how to handle these differences..
Thanks Uma, I hope so! At this moment, I am feeling pretty devastated as she cites her favorite people to be her father and some people in the extended family whom we meet like once a year! And I am not in the count as I don't smile very often. Can't believe how these little people perceive things!!
DeleteI think you handled it pretty well and she will keep coming to you in case she will have any doubts. You are doing just fine.
ReplyDeleteThanks Jas, I hope she does that! Normally she does not tell me anything that happens at class, have to really gig out info from her.
DeleteSorry, I meant dig out info from her.
Deleteyou are doing fine as a parent. and handled it well.
ReplyDeleteand I am sure she will tell you things , dont pressurise her t otell you everything because she will want some space of her own too..
although as a mom you will know what to do ..
Bikram's
Thanks, I think this time we were ok. Agree with the space bit, from Big G I really don't get a daily rundown of her day at school, it comes out as bits and pieces of info over periods of time:)
DeleteWow, you have a very wise head!!! I don't what i would have done if i had been in your situation...
ReplyDeleteThanks ZM, I seriously think this is just the beginning....I am only happy she came back and told me everything because normally I don't get to hear about her day at school in detail.
Delete